| Kindle | Forcing the Spring: Inside the Fight for Marriage Equality |
| By | |
| ISBN | 1594204446 |
| ISBN-13 | 9781594204449 |
| Publication | 11 March 2025 |
| Number of Pages | 480 |
| Format Type | Hardcover |
Forcing the springworks therapeutics
Becker was given free rein in the legal and political war rooms where the strategy of marriage equality was plotted She takes us inside the remarkable campaign that rebranded a movement into the Oval Office where the president and his advisors debated how to respond to a fast changing political landscape into the chambers of the federal judges who decided that today s bans on same sex marriage were no constitutional than previous century s bans on interracial marriage and into the mindsets of the Supreme Court judges who decided the California case and will likely soon decide the issue for the country at large From the state by state efforts to win marriage equality at the ballot box to the landmark Supreme Court case that struck down a law that banned legally married gay and lesbian couples from receiving federal benefits.
Forcing the spring jo becker
Things pick up and the book traces an interesting trajectory of the changes in the USA leading up to the case being heard by the Supreme Court. Kindle forcing the spring reddit I am sympathetic to Becker in the end She selected the Olson Boies case as the one that would make history for same sex marriage It just didn t work out that it did The Windsor case did That case however was argued primarily by women Robbie Kaplan and lesbians and was about an old lesbian I ask ironically who wants to write about old lesbians when there are really interesting young gay men to write about and august white guy lawyers Pity because it s the broads who made history Becker is a NYT journalist The old chestnut that journalism is the first draft of history is true This book is a first draft of the history of marriage equality Others are coming and will focus generously on activists and will locate women prominently 480
| Forcing the Spring: Inside the Fight for Marriage Equality By Jo Becker |
| 1594204446 |
| 9781594204449 |
| English |
| 480 |
| Hardcover |
| forcing the spring book |
| forcing spring bulbs |
| forcing spring bulbs in water |
| forcing spring branches |
| what forces act on a spring |
| spring rate to force |
| force formula for spring |
| spring book recommendations |
| forcing the spring pdf download |
| forcing the spring pdf free |
| forcing the spring pdf download free |
| pdf forcing the spring free |
| pdf forcing the spring free download |
| pdf forcing the springs |
| forcing the spring epub download |
Force formula for spring
A New York Times Notable Book of the Year A Washington Post Best Book of the Year Nonfiction A Kirkus Best Book of the Year A riveting legal drama a snapshot in time when the gay rights movement altered course and public opinion shifted with the speed of a bullet trainBecker s most remarkable accomplishment is to weave a spellbinder of a tale that despite a finale reported around the world manages to keep readers gripped until the very end The Washington Post A tour de force of groundbreaking reportage by Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Jo Becker Forcing the Spring is the definitive account of five remarkable years in American civil rights when the United States experienced a tectonic shift on the issue of marriage equality Beginning with the historical legal challenge of California s ban on same sex marriage Becker expands the scope to encompass all aspects of this momentous struggle offering a gripping behind the scenes narrative told with the lightning pace of the greatest legal thrillers For nearly five years Becker weaves together the political and legal forces that reshaped a nation Forcing the Spring begins with California s controversial ballot initiative Proposition 8 which banned gay men and lesbians from marrying the person they loved This electoral defeat galvanized an improbable alliance of opponents to the ban with political operatives and Hollywood royalty enlisting attorneys Ted Olson and David Boies the opposing counsels in the Supreme Court s Bush v Gore case to join together in a unique bipartisan challenge to the political status quo Despite initial opposition from the gay rights establishment the case against Proposition 8 would ultimately force the issue of marriage equality all the way to the Supreme Court transforming same sex marriage from a partisan issue into a modern crisis of civil rights Shuttling between the twin American power centers of Hollywood and Washington and based on access to all the key players in the Justice Department and the White House Becker offers insider coverage on the true story of how President Obama evolved to embrace marriage equality What starts out as a tale of an epic legal battle grows into the story of the evolution of a country Becker shows how the country reexamined its opinions on same sex marriage an issue that raced along with a snowballing velocity which astounded veteran political operatives Here is the ringside account of this unprecedented change the fastest shift in public opinion ever seen in modern American politics Clear eyed and even handed Forcing the Spring is political and legal journalism at its finest offering an unvarnished perspective on the extraordinary transformation of America and an inside look into the fight to win the rights of marriage and full citizenship for all Forcing the Spring Inside the Fight for Marriage Equality
You have to sympathize with the writer who thought this would be the case to establish national marriage equality Because it wasn t it s an anticlimax through no fault of Becker s It s no spoiler to say it was in fact a couple of nurses from suburban Detroit whose case made it all the way to SCOTUS without support from the Hollywood elite million dollar lawyers highly paid political consultants or PR gurus Though that case was in full swing by 2013 it doesn t even merit a passing mention in this book Some speculate SCOTUS ruled as it did in Hollingsworth v Perry because it expected the far precedent setting Michigan case to appear on their docket before long That s perhaps unfair and it s equally unfair to blame Becker for not including about the decades of LGBT civil rights struggles prior to Prop 8 That the book is marketed as Inside the fight for marriage equality is also unfair It s Inside one case that was particularly high profile Becker gambled on Prop 8 not Edie Windsor not the Michigan nurses and lost so we re lucky the book made it to print at all But that unfortunate subtitle should have been changed Throughout the book Becker appears starstruck and not just by Rob Reiner Lance Black and the case s celebrity entourage She s starstruck by the powerful attorneys by Cleve Jones by the President s inner circle I admire her narrative style in making a suspenseful story out of a lot of legal proceedings but all that starstrucking gets in the way This does not extend to the plaintiffs whom she treats very respectfully and I appreciated her ethical choice not to exploit them in any way Overall a worthwhile read for students of the movement SCOTUS and legal nerds but we ll have to wait to see if a book about the true fight and the victory for marriage equality is ever written 480 A book that actually made me think there is some good in this world Becker takes you inside both the human story of the challenges to and eventual defeat of prop 8 as well as the legal story The book is a pretty linear narrative that doesn t discuss a ton of gay history but if you have a little background there it isn t a problem Overall it is inspiring and heart warming but also highly informative on both how the justice system works and the arguments of both sides. Force done by spring Two fascinating aspects of this story stood out to me The first was the amount of image control and concern about the direction of history that went into this case The anti prop 8 ie pro gay marriage team had to defy most of established LGBT advocacy groups to launch this case because the estab wanted to pursue the political process incrementally Prop 8 which passed in liberal California was one of many blows this approach took in the 2000s and it plus the Obama election which created an anything is possible vibe on the team prompted the bold challenge to the law The team rigorously avoided A Looking too gay or straying too far from the norm hence the choice two fairly normal couples to bring the suit a pride parade this effort wasn t and B Going too far in saying the other side was motivated by hatred Of course the case hinged in part on the argument that Prop 8 was motivated by animus and not by any compelling rational state interest which was definitely true Also even the courts themselves by the second Obama term were starting to think that because gay marriage rigths was advancing so quickly at the state level in a reversal of the previous decade that maybe it was better to rule narrowly Of course people s rights and equality shouldn t depend on the direction of history so I was a bit confused by this. Forcing the springvale maine The 2nd really interesting aspect of this story is that the pro prop 8 team s argument was so narrow The Prop 8 movement especially in evangelical and Mormon churches was willing to say horrific things about gay people but the legal team narrowed their case down to A The vague claim that gay marriages would redefine the institution of marriage which is inherently tied to childbearing and raising a ridiculously easy argument to refute and B the argument that we should leave it to the states because in a generally Burkean sense we don t know how changing marriage will affect society at large The second point is basically playing for time because there was no evidence in states and countries that had gay marriage that it harmed anyone or anything in fact it strengthens marriage The first point is likely arguing that integrating baseball or whatever changed the nature of the game Same game buddy the only difference is natural procreation but of course no one stops the elderly or the voluntarily childless or the infertile from marrying or would consider their marriages to be less than So it was interesting that the anti gay marriage case went out with a whimper rather than a bang it was I suppose a great thing given that gay marriage has faded into normalcy in our society. Forcing the spring pdf download One caveat this book takes you to the SC allowing Judge Vaughan s striking down of Prop 8 to stand as well as the striking down of DOMA in the US v WIndsor case It does NOT take you all the way to Obergefell which was mildly disappointing Still a great book that made me hopeful about our country in a time when things haven t been great Love wins 480 Forcing the Spring Inside the Fight for Marriage Equality by Jo BeckerQuick Impression This is merely one chapter in the broader story towards marriage equality A fascinating read this publication was controversial when it was released for it s uneven coverage of grassroots and racial contributions to the gay rights movement and it s heavily heteronormative lens Despite these shortcomings I found it a valuable work of reportage that read today highlights that the route to progress is hardly ever perfect or pure The Long Version I have so many thoughts about this book That said I will start this review by saying that I found it incredibly informative valuable and incredibly accessible reading I ll be honest and say that I only knew of the Supreme Court decisions of June 2013 in very broad strokes I had followed the campaign to overturn Proposition 8 or less via social media and rejoiced with the rest of the world when it was overthrown Beyond that my knowledge on the subject I imagine was like most people As a work of reportage on the case this book gives a great beginner s overview of the cases the players the legal arguments for each side and the verdict What the book does not do is apply a critical reading or analysis of this story Becker s coverage is typical of the reporting on such issues in the Obama era There s a sense of mission accomplished self satisfaction to a lot of the political writing prior to 2016 and this book no exception To be fair not many people could have predicted the world would be as it is today However through the power of hindsight reading a book like this which gives enormous credit to liberal elites party bipartisanship Hollywood moguls and white heteronormative queers one can certainly look back to a quainter idealistic time The fact that Trumpism and the political tribalism that exists today likely grew out of this rapturous self congratulatory environment is really hard to dismiss Nevertheless I still think this book is worth reading both as a historical telling of a landmark verdict but also as a cultural artifact of a very different time As a gay man there s plenty I didn t know about the two cases that were decided on in the summer of 2013 To begin how many people are aware that the main lawyer fighting for marriage equality Ted Olson was also a staunch Republican conservative who argued in front of the Supreme Court in Bush v Gore securing George W Bush s presidency How many people know that the main lawyer arguing against marriage equality Chuck Cooper has an out and proud lesbian daughter with whom he is very close How many people know that upon filing of the lawsuit to overturn Proposition 8 many gay rights organizations did not support litigation Finally how many people know that Chief Justice Roberts and that conservative lion of the bench Antonin Scalia actually voted with the majority to overturn Prop 8 while liberal Sonya Sotomayor and Anthony Kennedy dissented The reasons for this are infinitely complex than can be written about here so if you re interested let s talk about it offline All these facts and left me floored about how ignorant I had been about this historical landmark While at the time this book was likely regarded as a victory lap reading it today it seems like a litany of warnings for progressive politics purity politics can sometimes derail you bipartisanship is essential to achieving anything worthwhile centering whiteness in social movements does little to help other people of colour gain equality and recognition reliance on Hollywood elites for support and funding can leave many politicians looking out of touch with everyday affairs It really is fascinating how the book has aged in the last 6 years since it s been published as this surely was not the author s intention Despite its flaws I highly encourage people to pick this book up There s a lot to learn and discuss 480 I enjoyed this book on some level but I found it hard to get through The reality is the equality movement didn t start in 2008 with Prop 8 and it didn t end in 2013 with the SCOTUS ruling This an in depth look at people who worked very hard on one case 480 This was a fascinating inside look into one of the most contentious cases in recent memory The author followed the plaintiffs throughout the litigation process and conducted interviews with the defendants and judges afterwards It leans heavily in favor of marriage equality but so do I Everyone should read it for both the insider commentary and to examine the arguments for and against marriage equality in the light of court argument It is a captivating read but then what legal history isn t 480 I ve read the book through and can say that if you ignore the conclusory opening and closing chapters the flawed premises that the marriage revolution started in 2008 and that this was a decisive victory at the Supreme Court it s OK as a courtroom drama The Proposition 8 Federal trial and appeals takes up most of the book and once the case gets going her narrative is straightforward enough She did seem according to her source notes to have access to attorneys Ted Olsen and Charles Cooper to Hollywood activist Rob Reiner and to Judge Walker whose personal reflections are perhaps the one big revelation in this book. Force done by spring Just as background I was one of those pushing domestic partner registry ordinances 20 years ago and took a low level part in the No on 8 campaign and saw its inadequacies I was one of 18000 marriages done in mid 2008 and at risk if Prop 8 passed Still it s irksome for her to conclude that the struggle only started in Nov 2008 when in fact lawyers Olsen and Boies and Ms Becker for that matter happened to get into this story just as they reached a tipping point after all the years of incremental and concerted work And it s worth noting that this case s final outcome was something of a fizzle the Supreme Court invalidated Prop 8 only on a matter of standing not the merits and the decisive case that session was Windsor v U. Forcing the springworks therapeutics Perhaps Ms Becker couldn t have known that Edie Windsor s case would empower a new wave of Federal rulings on state anti marriage equality laws which only now spring 2014 are reaching circuit court level and heading for the Supreme Court Still it would be nice if we had the same kind of book about Edie Windsor and the anti DOMA cases that paralleled hers or for that matter it would be good to see a stand alone memoir by Judge Walker. Forcing the spring kindle paperwhite So this serves simply as a trial story written in a newspaperish and somewhat dramatic way It s not the final story nor does it help the reader appreciate what this story is in full context see e. Epub forcing the spring pdf Victory The Triumphant Gay Revolution for histories of the movement For that matter given Ms Becker s invocations of Harvey Milk or his City Hall bust it would help to read The Mayor of Castro Street The Life and Times of Harvey Milk to realize just how far the movement came from 1978 to 2008 But you the reader will have to do that reading and I wonder if she did. Kindle forcing the spring reddit Like the Supreme Court ruling on this case this book ends up being about procedure Not the merits 480 Forcing the Spring Inside the Fight for Marriage Equality A ReviewWith Forcing the Spring Jo Becker writes a tour de force that is enhanced by its level of insider information to the ultimate 2013 Supreme Court case Hollingsworth v Perry Becker traces the case from its very inception following the passage of Proposition 8 in California eliminating the right of same sex couples to marry by ballot initiative to the ultimate decision of the Supreme Court that the plaintiffs supporters of Prop 8 did not have standing to intervene This decision paved the way for same sex marriages to continue in California Given her access to many of the actors in the case as it was playing out Becker is able to recount aspects of the story that would otherwise be lost to history key decision points development of strategy and personal details that enrich the tale. Forcing the spring epub free download This book captures an important historical moment in the struggle for marriage equality and on a grander stage the LGBT movement in general In the context of civil rights both to posterity and to perpetuity Becker in telling this story makes a valuable contribution This story recollects a pivotal moment in the marriage equality endgame Certainly despite the thrust of the narrative at times marriage equality did not begin with the fight against Prop 8 but it does represent strategic key decisions made by dedicated individuals to take the fight to the end at this time over the objection of experienced voices angling for a pragmatic approach For people like me ravenous readers of courtroom drama and or advocates of marriage equality this narrative nonfiction is one of the contemporary best in its genre The author has a firm grasp of drama and successfully uses every literary trick to hook the reader Even when I knew the outcome of certain situations I was still traveling through the story with a heightened sense of suspense This is no small homage to Becker It is a monumental task for authors in recounting historical events to hook and maintain the reader s attention as they are pulled toward a known outcome In this book Becker masters the art It cannot be overstated that the actors especially the lawyers Ted Olson the man who successfully argued for George W Bush in the infamous Supreme Court case Bush v Gore and David Boies the man who unsuccessfully argued for Al Gore in the same case were taking a huge risk in seeking full marriage equality from the United States Supreme Court at the time that they did Were it to fail there is a very strong argument to be made that it would have set the marriage equality movement back years if not decades To some degree the reason this is such a compelling story is because of the outcome which is spun as a win for marriage equality when at best it was a draw with the Court ruling that Prop 8 supporters had improperly brought the case But for all intents and purposes this story could just as easily have been a loss at one point according to Becker Boies puts their chances at success at 50 50 in which case we would all be reading the heroic stories of those who cautioned against such rapid movement for marriage equality and bemoaning the foolhardy arrogance of Olson and Boies So in a sense while the book portrays this team as brilliant and calculated that the stars aligned to bring these individuals together for this moment there is a certain aura of luck cast over the events that tarnishes the carefully polished gleam to some small degree Becker has received some criticism for advocating the story to the detriment of narration This is not unwarranted The book is billed as a journalist s inside story of the fight for marriage equality however there is a marked opinion to the telling Becker by her own account supports marriage equality and clearly admires the team seeking to destroy barriers to marriage for same sex couples in the first paragraph she cleverly equates Chad Griffin one of her protagonists to Rosa Parks Further than this though it is evident in the writing When Becker does not have much access to an individual or does not find them appealing either to the story or to her own liking she writes things like Boies grinned Some people become bashful when paid a compliment He was not among them It is worth noting however that Becker was granted near full access to the Olson Boies team and almost none to the opposing team As a result much of the story is necessarily told from the perspective of those fighting against Prop 8 which could explain why it appears to be such advocacy Becker also reaches to structure and support a narrative that marriage equality required the marriage no pun intended of conservatives and liberals alike The author almost fawns over Ted Olson the conservative and his relationship with the story s liberals The reader is regularly reminded via anecdote and sometimes quite bluntly that Olson and by extension his conservatism is an indispensable tool in the success of marriage equality She treats Ken Mehlman a gay political operative who maneuvered George W Bush s successful 2004 presidential campaign likewise The liberal characters on the other hand while quite strong and influential activists in and of themselves are often relegated to repeating how surprised they are that they actually like Olson and Mehlman This narrative construct is almost certainly offensive to marriage equality advocates such as Evan Wolfson Tim Gill and Andrew Sullivan to name just a few that dedicated their lives to the cause and were given overt short shrift in this book In fact the author seems at times to take great pains to extricate herself from journalistic discipline specifically to take petty potshots at these LGBT community giants In the end the struggle for any author is appeal In structuring the story the way that she has Becker weaves a riveting tale but the appeal may be limited Despite her best efforts to cast a wide marketing net best evidenced by her lionizing of a conservative s dedication to the fight her lack of journalistic narration might limit this book s appeal to a relatively fixed audience liberal supporters of marriage equality 480 I loved this book It had a great balance of legal depth and personal drama As a Californian I was completely unaware of the DOMA struggle going on in New York while the whole Prop 8 battle went on here I also was delighted to learn about the significant Republican support same sex marriage has begun to capture Well written and easy to read 480 This week another major argument for same sex marriage was brought before the U. Forcing the springy time I was keenly interested in learning the strategy and background that went into our side winning the two major cases that went to SCOTUS in 2013 For me my spouse and my activist friends that day in June when we learned that Prop 8 in California and DOMA were stuck down was exhilarating. Forcing spring bulbs in water So back to Forcing the Spring Jo Becker is a journalist for the New York Times and she had inside access to the team who fought Proposition 8 While she interviews the key players in the DOMA case the gracious and determined Edie Windsor and her attorney Becker wasn t as close to that camp Alas we get a book that focuses at times on Prop 8 trivia while we are panting to learn about Edie and her legal marriage to Thea which happened when both were in their late 70s The first half of this book was hard to get through Prop 8 was fought by Hollywood celebrities their friends and two celebrity lawyers Olsen and Boies Give me Edie please. Forcing the spring pdf download The LOFT an LGBT community center in White Plains gave Edie an award in 2012 the year before her case went to the Supreme Court She was 82 elegant and articulate She took the podium and said Thanks for giving me this humongous award Now let me tell you why I am suing the United States of America. Spring rate to force My other complaint about Becker She deified Lance Black and Chad Griffin some younger new Hollywood connected activists And demonized activists like Evan Wolfson who was fighting for marriage even years before I came out of the closet Really Was that necessary 480 Forcing the Spring actually picks up in the second half I found the opening mean and ungenerous to LGBT activists many who had been working for years on queer equality The second section is a blow by blow account of the trial in SF and it is about as interesting as watching a trial which is to say paint a bedroom and then watch the paint dry for two weeks while a chemist explains to you the process of paint drying After the trial though.